If you are looking for a challenge play Mystic Rock. It is a former PGA tour event course and will give you a good run for your money. Shepards rock is more wide open bigger fairways and greens. You can knock it around and enjoy yourself. In the end both courses are always in great shape you wont regret your decision either way.

Ended up playing Mystic and was blown away by the conditions and Pete's layout is truly incredible! Also, the practice facilities and locker room/pro shop are next level! Didn't know so many greats have played there like Vijay who won the 84 Lumber Classic back in 2004, Stewart Cink was runner up, and Pat Perez and Zach Johnson finished third that year. Tiger played a Pro Am a few months after his Masters Win back in 1997(When I was Born) and through his and John Daly's efforts they got the PGA to work with Joe Hardy(Nemacolin's Founder) and became the host for the former Pennsylvania Classic through 2006!